Barry
Crawshaw monitors the MS5500. Featured
in the MMM-Marketplace section, March 2003 issue, pages 175-176.
MMM
MONITORED PRODUCTS - Developments with VDO
In
the light of experience For
the last 10,000 miles of motorcaravan driving, I have had the use of a navigation
system. From it I have derived more satisfaction than any other piece of equipment.
On our ever more crowded roads, I am reluctant to slow to a crawl when looking
for a hidden junction for fear of antagonising the impatient throng behind, with
the consequent dangers. With the navigator, I know just where that invisible turning
is, and can signal and adjust speed at exactly the correct spot. The displayed
countdown of distance to the turning is just one of the treats that the system
provides.
In
April 2002 (p163), I described the early months
of an extended trial of the VDO Dayton MS5000 navigation system. This covered
the equipment and its installation, and my initial experience during the first
few hundred miles of use. Here I shall mention some of my reactions after a full
year's use of the system, and developments that have taken place with the equipment
that is on the market.
Understandably,
I have developed quite a dependence upon the thing, with its disembodied imperturbable
voice crystal-clear maps, and comprehend-at-a-glance diagrams of junctions. As
most of my driving is on unfamiliar roads, the VDO (as I call it, for short) has
restored even solo driving to being a pleasure instead of a pain. However carefully
I prepare a route plan from paper map, I am inevitably thrown by poor signing,
unnamed streets, and other hazards. My continually finding somewhere to pull in
and re-plan is frustrating for me and an irritation to following traffic. The
VDO eliminates that downside of travelling.
Although
we find guidance to a destination to be the most useful function, it is helpful
on quiet roads (where route finding is easy) for Muriel simply to watch the vehicle
marker make its magic way across the map, keeping a check on progress. ("Have
we passed that crossroads with D492 yet?") Yes, we still use paper atlases and
sheet maps, and enjoy the great variety of detail they show.
"For
the last 10,000 miles of motorcaravan driving, I have had the use of a navigation
system. From it I have derived more satisfaction than any other piece of equipment."
New
model of VDO navigational computer (MS5500) and a selection of screen displays.
I
have experimented further with the speed warning function, but seldom use it now.
Turning it on and off, and adjusting between the various speed limits needs to
be done too often; and I observe speed limits carefully anyhow.
Under
the 'route selection' heading's two main choices, there is no ideal. 'Shortest'
really is just that, sooner or later taking you along back-streets that are simply
too narrow or cluttered to weave a motorcaravan through. 'Fastest' I have come
to interpret as the most free-flowing, reasonably direct route. This may or may
not get you to the destination in the shortest possible time or at the highest
possible average speed. It may add many miles to your journey in order to give
you motorway (or similar standard) roads. For example, near home, I was given
a devious 22-mile route when the direct 11-mile route is entirely satisfactory.
On another occasion, I was taken along two sides of a triangle of motorways. 'Fastest'
may suit lorries that need to avoid narrow roads with tight corners: 'shortest'
will be fine for cars that can nip through the back- streets. Motorcaravans could
do with a middle course, but that could be difficult to programme, and none of
the navigation systems seem to offer that compromise.
The
moral of all that is to preview the planned route on the screen before departing
and, if necessary, to add 'via points' to force the route to your preference.
That brings me to one of my dissatisfactions with the basic guidance programme.
Once you insert a 'via point', the planned route is displayed on the map screen
only as far as that point. You cannot check the 'via point's' effect on the remainder
of the route.
When
a manoeuvre is being approached, the system gives an advance warning and more
detailed instructions later. The position at which the instruction is given is
speed-dependent so that, at whatever speed you are driving you receive the instructions
a set time before the manoeuvre. In tight, city-centre situations, junctions can
come in quick succession. Sometimes the instructions come too late for a lane
change to be considerate to others or even safe.
My
only other serious complaint will, I hope, like the one above, soon be ironed
out. The diction of the recorded words from which the instructions are synthesised
was consistently excellent in the first version of the software I used. In a more
recent version that I am using at present the words first and third (referring,
for example to roundabout exits) are scarcely distinguishable.
Of
the many Continental countries for which there are VDO maps (on CD), I have had
the opportunity to try out only the one for France. Its style of mapping is identical
to that used for the UK though slightly fewer minor roads seem to be shown. I
have found that many motorcaravanners, venturing abroad for the first time are
nervous about the challenges of driving there. I am sure that the use of a navigator
such as VDO would greatly ease the stress, as the system even shows the anti-clockwise
passage through roundabouts.
To
conclude this part, the weaknesses I have highlighted above are far, far outweighed
by the advantages of a navigation system. I emphasise the value of being piloted
through unfamiliar cities, even abroad, of not getting lost in a maze of unsigned
country lanes, of knowing exactly where you have reached, all without the human
navigator of the team having slavishly to follow on a map.
"The
MSS5000 system remains available, priced at £1500 including Britain map and installation
by Conrad Anderson (see below). Installation can be carried out either at their
works in Birmingham, or at a mutually arranged location, to which travel by the
installer is charged at 35p per mile. VDO map disks for Britain still cost £150
for the TMC version, and £100 without. A set of eight disks for Europe (with TMC)
costs £280."
Recent
developments of the MS5000
1. Early in 2002, the Traffic Message Channel (TMC) facility came into operation
in Britain (and was already operational in the major Continental countries covered
by VDO). The installation of a small VHF receiver and aerial allows the reception
of signals that carry information about road congestion and other conditions such
as fog. Symbols, which indicate the type of problem, are then superimposed upon
the screen map. If delays extend over large distances, this is displayed on a
separate diagram, and the VDO offers to calculate a detour that will return you
to your original route beyond the obstruction.
2.
Guidance: For planning a route to a particular street name, the normal
sequence is to enter first the town name (you may have to guess the nearest town
to a hamlet or small village), then the street name.
Later
software allows you to enter the street name first, then to select the town from
a list that appears. This ('QXS' method) is a little quicker unless the street
has a common name such as High Street!
3.
Postcodes provide a brief, unique location for streets and large individual
establishments. Here is the good news: the latest guidance software does accept
'abbreviated' postcodes (the initial letters and the digits) for guidance to a
destination.
I should have liked grid references. They are so useful, being found in
many campsite guides (including those of the two big clubs), AA touring guides,
and many other publications. Perhaps there simply is not enough demand across
the whole of this market, and they are virtually unique to the British Isles.
New
model unveiled
Last
November, I was privileged to be one of the first motorists in Britain to see
a radically new model of VDO Navigator demonstrated. This MS5500 system is new
in regard to the computer, the software, and the way of gaining access to the
most up-to-date mapping.
The new computer has an improved processor, which gives much faster access to
the maps (now on DVD), faster movement around the operating menus, and faster
route calculation (about 10 seconds from London to mid-Scotland). The new software
contains an increased number of facilities and some relatively minor but very
valuable improvements, such as showing on the screen the scale of the map in use.
Previously that was not shown, so, unless you could remember the scale you had
set earlier you could not estimate distances from the screen.
Most
radical of all is the new (C-IQ) method of providing map data. With the MS5000,
described above, you buy a map CD for each country according to your requirements.
These cost around £100 or, for the TMC version £150. So you are not likely to
renew them very often! With the MS5500, the arrangement for access to maps is
quite different. You are supplied ('free') with a DVD that contains all the map
and other data for the whole of VDO's European coverage. To obtain access to this
data, you buy as much time for each country as you wish, from a day to a year
Thus, if you were to make a motorcaravan trip to Switzerland (where better?),
you might buy two days at the start and two at the end for transits through France,
and three weeks for Switzerland. Normally, the user will take a full year's use
of their home country.
This
map access can be ordered by phone or through the VDO web site. Authorisation,
in the form of an access code to the VDO computer; can be sent to the customer
by phone, e-mail, or (SMS) text message. The map disc content is in four parts,
each of which can be selected separately as desired. They are the mapping (23
countries); the TMC data (11 countries); useful information, such as the location
of fuel stations, TICs, museums; and many other features of interest to the tourist;
and finally 'guidebook' information (including pictures), such as in Michelin
and Varta guides.
The
MSS5000 system remains available, priced at £1500 including Britain map and installation
by Conrad Anderson (see below). Installation can be carried out either at their
works in Birmingham, or at a mutually arranged location, to which travel by the
installer is charged at 35p per mile. VDO map disks for Britain still cost £150
for the TMC version, and £100 without. A set of eight disks for Europe (with TMC)
costs £280.
For
the new MS5500 system, there is a choice of screen sizes. With a 5.8inch screen
(MM5000), the recommended retail price is £1700. With a 7inch screen (MM5500),
it is £1800. For access to the map data on the DVD, the price per region (such
as UK) ranges from €3 per day to €90 per year. For access to all Europe, the corresponding
prices are €8 to €179. Access fees are charged to subscribers in Euros, and the
above figures are an approximate guide only It is also possible to buy 'lifetime
access' at about €170 per country or €360 ;or Europe, including the UK.
For
prices of the MS5500 equipment and its installation, contact Conrad Anderson at
the address below.
Do
you want a product that is not listed on this site?
If
so Freephone within the UK 0800 279 0085.
Conrad
Anderson provide a fitting service with
free electric hook-up & water. Customers
wishing to stay overnight may do so. See
the Fittingpage
for details.
Technical Helpline: 0870 872 2998 Telephone: 0121 247 0619 Fax: 0121 247 0974 Order products by telephone or fax or by using our order
form. Opening
Hours: Monday - Friday 9.00 - 17.30 and Saturday 9.00 - 13.00.